Red State, Blue City
Publication Date: 2/2/2017
- Author:David A. Graham
- Publication:The Atlantic
...But if liberal advocates are clinging to the hope that federalism will allow them to create progressive havens, they're overlooking a big problem: Power may be decentralized in the American system, but it devolves to the state, not the city. Recent events in red states where cities are pockets of liberalism are instructive, and cautionary. Over the past few years, city governments and state legislatures have fought each other in a series of battles involving preemption, the principle that state law trumps local regulation, just as federal law supersedes state law. It hasn't gone well for the city dwellers.
Close observers of these clashes expect them to proliferate in the years to come, with similar results. "We are about to see a shit storm of state and federal preemption orders, of a magnitude greater than anything in history," says Mark Pertschuk of Grassroots Change, which tracks such laws through an initiative called Preemption Watch. By the group's count, at least 36 states introduced laws preempting cities in 2016...